[Gieferg]

Giefeg napisał(a):Jak kiedyś zrobiłem fanedit całego LOTRa, który się zamykał w 3,5h, to właśnie w tym miejscu się kończył (pomijał też reunion w sypialni przechodząc od sceny z orłami niosącymi Froda i Sama bezpośrednio do koronacji).

Teraz się przymierzam do odtworzenia tego w HD, udało mi się wygrzebać listę zmian na fanedit.org:

Cytat:The Fellowship of the Ring (86 minutes)

- prologue replaced with much shorter version with Christopher Lee reading Verse of The Rings
- Shire scenes trimmed heavily (this is the part of the edit which I am least happy with)
- duel of the wizards deleted
- after first encounter with the Nazgul there is cut straight to Bree
- many cuts made to the events between Bree and Rivendell
- there is no Mithril vest in this version
- Caradhras deleted, after Gimli suggesting going through Moria there is cut straight to Moria
- watcher deleted
- journey through Moria is much shorter
- no stairs action sequence
- Lothlorien is shortened to three scenes - arrival, Galadriel's mirror and farewell (all of them trimmed)
- there is only a few seconds of travelling by the river
- many cuts to final battle which is more focused on Boromir now

The Two Towers (60 minutes)


- this part is most focused on Aragorn, Gimli and Legolas
- Arwen is entirely cut from this part
- only two scenes with Frodo and Sam are in - first, when they meet Gollum, and second one is conversation when Gollum is trying to catch a fish
- Faramir is completely removed from this version of the film
- we see Merry and Pipin only three times, first one is when they meet Treebeard, second one is when they make him see what Saruman has done with the forest, and third one is of

course when ents are destroying Isengard.
- we meet Eomer, Eowyn, Theoden and Grima when Aragorn & co. meet them for a first time
- shorter version of Gandalf vs Balrog battle from the beginning of the movie is moved to reunion with Gandalf scene
- no wargs attack scene
- there are no scenes with crying women and children in Helm's Deep
- most of the scenes during waiting for Saruman's army arrival deleted
- battle heavily trimmed
- defending the gate deleted
- Haldir's death deleted (I wanted to keep it, but he is not that important character so he just vanished, killed offscreen)
- reworked ending includes only Helm's Deep and Isengard scenes without Sam's voiceover

Return of the King (84 minutes)

- film starts with Isengard scene from EE (trimmed)
- Arwen has only one scene (at the end) in this part
- Denethor is present in only two scenes and one quick shot
- many scenes which don't move the action forward were deleted
- when Aragorn tells Theoden that Gondor is calling for help, king does not hesitate and they depart immediately
- Elrond does not say anything about Arwen's dying
- Path of the Dead ends in the similar way as in theatrical version
- Minas Tirith siege and battle with oliphants are heavily trimmed
- Shelob's fight is much shorter
- when Sam is going to rescue Frodo orcs don't go berserk and kill each other, it looks like there was only few of them
- journey through Mordor is much shorter
- Black gate sequence is similar like in theatrical version
- battle at the Black Gate has been trimmed, Aragorn doesn't fight with troll
- Mount Doom's scenes are rearranged and shortened there is much less switching from it to Black Gate and back again
- film ends after Frodo says that fellowship of the ring was ended
- Galadriel's Song of Eldamar as ending song

Za rok to samo czeka Hobbita :]